Pupford Freeze-Dried Training Treats Review for Border Collie Owners

Bag of Pupford freeze-dried beef liver training treats for dogs and puppies, 4 oz

Our verdict

Pupford beef liver treats suit Border Collie owners who train a lot and want a light, small, strong-smelling reward that won’t grease up a pouch. The listing promises 475+ treats in a 4 oz bag and only three ingredients. Skip them if your dog is on a restricted diet, or if you dislike handling liver, and expect crumbs at the bottom of the bag.

  • Best for: High-volume, high-value training
  • Not for: Dogs on special diets
  • Bag size for most Border Collies: 4 oz

Check price on Amazon

Kibble works fine in the kitchen. It does not work in a field where a Border Collie has just caught the scent of sheep on the other side of the hedge. At that moment you’re competing with a few thousand years of breeding, and you need a reward your dog will actually turn around for. For a lot of dogs, that’s liver.

The problem with most liver treats is mess and calories. Fresh liver is slimy, homemade liver cake crumbles, and big jerky strips mean stopping to break pieces off. Pupford’s freeze-dried training treats aim to fix that with tiny, dry, light pieces you can carry in a pocket. This review sticks to the beef liver version and what its listing says, read against the way collies actually train.

What Pupford Freeze-Dried Training Treats are (and aren't)

These are freeze-dried training treats sold in several flavors, including chicken, salmon, rabbit and sweet potato. This review covers beef liver. According to the listing, the beef liver recipe has only three ingredients, is described as ultra low-calorie, and a 4 oz bag holds 475+ treats. The brand calls them suitable for all breed sizes and for puppies.

Pupford’s main pitch is practical: small pieces for quick rewards, and no oily, greasy or crumbly mess on your hands or in your pouch. The brand says you can keep a few in your pocket on walks without them going grimy or stale.

What they aren’t is a chew or a filling snack. Each piece is tiny by design. They’re also not the cheapest way to fill a treat pouch, so many owners mix them with kibble or a mid-value soft treat.

Key specs

Brand Pupford
Product Freeze Dried Training Treats, Beef Liver
Type Freeze-dried
Ingredients 3, per the listing
Treats per bag 225+ (2 oz), 475+ (4 oz), 1400+ (4 oz, 3 pack)
Suitable for Dogs and puppies, all breed sizes
Other flavors listed Chicken, salmon, rabbit, sweet potato and more

Which size fits a Border Collie

All three options are the same beef liver treat. Freeze-dried treats keep well when sealed, so the bigger packs make sense if you train every day.

Small 2 oz bag of Pupford freeze-dried beef liver training treats

2 oz bag

About 225+ treats, per the listing. A good trial size to check your collie likes them.

View 2 oz bag

4 oz bag of Pupford freeze-dried beef liver training treats

4 oz bag Our pick

475+ treats, according to Pupford. Enough for a few weeks of regular collie training sessions.

View 4 oz bag

Three 4 oz bags of Pupford freeze-dried beef liver training treats

4 oz, 3 pack

1400+ treats in total. Worth it if you’re in puppy classes, herding lessons or sports training several times a week.

View 4 oz, 3 pack

What we like

Tiny pieces for lots of reps

Border Collies thrive on a high rate of reward when learning something new. Being able to hand out many small treats without filling the dog up keeps it hungry for the next rep, and keeps the session moving.

Clean in a pouch or pocket

Freeze-dried treats are dry and light. Pupford says they won’t leave oily or greasy residue, so they’re easy to carry in a coat pocket for those surprise training moments on walks, like a calm look at a passing bike.

High value without the slime

Liver is a favorite reward for many dogs, and freeze-dried liver gives you the smell without handling fresh liver. For recall practice near livestock, wildlife or other dogs, that extra value can make a real difference with a collie.

There’s a reason to protect that value, though. If liver becomes the everyday treat, it stops being special. Many collie owners keep a separate jar of something like Pupford that only comes out for recall, so the dog learns that coming back on the first call is when the best stuff appears.

Easy to scatter for calm sniffing

Small, dry pieces are easy to toss into the grass for a short sniff game. That’s handy with a collie that gets wound up on walks. Sniffing out a few scattered treats tends to bring arousal down, and it gives you a quick reset before you ask for focus again.

What we don’t like

Crumbs at the bottom

Freeze-dried treats are light and brittle, so some dust and broken bits are normal by the end of a bag. You can sprinkle the crumbs on a meal or a lick mat rather than tossing them.

Liver is rich

Liver is rich and some dogs’ stomachs don’t love a sudden increase. Start slowly, keep portions sensible, and talk to your vet if your collie has a sensitive stomach or a special diet.

Calorie detail isn't on the listing

The listing says ultra low-calorie but doesn’t give an exact per-treat number on Amazon. Check the bag and count them toward your dog’s daily intake like any other treat.

Pros

  • Small, light pieces for many reps
  • Only three ingredients, per the brand
  • Clean to carry, no greasy residue
  • Liver is high value for many dogs
  • Several bag sizes and flavors

Cons

  • Crumbs build up in the bag
  • Liver can be rich for some stomachs
  • Exact calories not shown on the listing

Tips to get the most from it

  • Keep Pupford treats as your top-tier reward for recall and hard distractions so they stay special.
  • Mix a handful into your dog’s kibble in a sealed tub; the kibble picks up the smell and becomes a better everyday reward.
  • Seal the bag tightly after each use so the treats don’t soften in damp weather.
  • Introduce slowly, a few pieces a day at first, especially with a puppy.
  • Use the crumbs on a lick mat or in a snuffle mat for a calming job after a busy walk.
  • If you’re working near livestock, check with the farmer first and keep your collie on a long line until the recall is solid.

Alternatives worth a look

Blue Buffalo Blue Bits A soft chicken treat that’s easy to tear and good for middle-value, everyday reps. See our Blue Bits review.

Stewart Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Another freeze-dried beef liver treat, worth comparing if you want a second liver option to rotate with.

Frequently asked questions

Are Pupford treats okay for Border Collie puppies?

Pupford says they're for dogs and puppies of all breed sizes. Start with a few pieces a day and ask your vet how treats fit into your growing puppy's total diet.

How many Pupford treats can I give in a session?

The pieces are small, so a collie can get plenty without being overfed, but check the calorie information on the bag. Keep total treats to roughly a tenth of daily calories and trim meals on heavy training days.

Do freeze-dried treats go bad once opened?

They keep best sealed and dry. Close the bag firmly after each use and follow any storage guidance on the package.

Which Pupford flavor is best for a Border Collie?

It depends on the dog. Beef liver is a strong-smelling favorite for many, while chicken or salmon may suit dogs that prefer a milder taste. The 2 oz bag is a sensible way to test a flavor.

Bottom line

Pupford’s beef liver treats are a good tool for the hardest part of training a Border Collie: getting a response when something more interesting is happening. They’re tiny, clean to carry, and high value for many dogs, with a short ingredient list.

Get the 4 oz bag, keep it for big moments, and mix in lower-value rewards for routine work. Your collie will notice the difference, and so will your recall.

Check price on Amazon

We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our verdict.