Best Dog Food for Border Collies to Gain Weight Safely

Border Collies are naturally lean. A fit Collie shows a clear waist and you can feel every rib under a thin layer of padding. Plenty of owners worry their dog is too skinny when it’s actually in perfect working shape. But some Collies really do struggle to hold weight, especially young, high-drive dogs, rescues and dogs coming back from illness.

Before anything else: if your dog has lost weight without a change in routine, see your vet. Worms, dental pain, gut problems and thyroid issues can all cause weight loss, and no food will fix those. If your vet gives the all-clear, the products below are the easiest ways to add healthy calories.

Our picks at a glance

Product Best for
VICTOR Hi-Pro Plus A calorie-dense main food Check price
Purina ONE True Instinct, Beef & Salmon Dogs that won’t finish meals Check price
Stella & Chewy’s Super Beef Meal Mixer Getting a fussy dog to eat Check price
All American Canine Weight Gainer Powder Adding calories without volume Check price
Miracle Vet High-Calorie Weight Gainer Gel Dogs recovering from illness Check price

How we chose these products

We looked for calorie-dense, complete foods with high protein and fat, plus a few add-ons that pack calories into a small serving. We skipped products that rely mainly on sugar or cheap fillers to add weight. We also favored brands with a long record over newer, unknown supplement makers.

Product details and images come from Amazon’s product data. We link to the live listing for current prices.

The best foods and add-ons to help a Border Collie gain weight

1. VICTOR Hi-Pro Plus

Best overall

VICTOR Hi-Pro Plus calorie dense dry dog food bag

With 30% protein and 20% fat, Hi-Pro Plus packs a lot of calories into each cup. That’s exactly what a dog that can’t eat huge volumes needs. Its multi-meat recipe of beef, chicken, pork and fish meals is also popular with picky working dogs.

Because it’s so dense, the same volume of food delivers more energy. Many hard keepers start gaining within a few weeks of switching, without having to eat more.

Pros

  • Lots of calories per cup
  • High protein to build muscle, not just fat
  • Rated for all life stages

Cons

  • Switch slowly to avoid loose stools
  • Must cut back once target weight is reached

Check price on Amazon

2. Purina ONE True Instinct, Beef & Salmon

Best for picky eaters

Purina ONE True Instinct beef and salmon dry dog food bag

Some thin Collies aren’t burning too much, they’re just not eating enough. The mix of crunchy kibble and tender, meaty morsels in True Instinct is more tempting than plain kibble, and protein sits at 32%.

It’s a mid-priced food you can find almost anywhere, which helps if you need to switch quickly.

Pros

  • Tempting texture mix
  • 32% protein
  • Easy to find

Cons

  • Not as calorie-dense as VICTOR
  • Some dogs pick out the morsels

Check price on Amazon

3. Stella & Chewy’s Super Beef Meal Mixer

Best topper

Stella and Chewy's freeze dried raw Super Beef Meal Mixer bag

Freeze-dried raw beef with organ and bone, crumbled over kibble. It smells strongly of meat, which is what wins over a Collie that turns its nose up at dinner. It’s 95% grass-fed beef, so the calories that come with it are protein and fat, not fillers.

Freeze-dried raw is expensive per pound. Use a small amount as a topper, not as the meal.

Pros

  • Very appealing smell and taste
  • Real meat calories
  • Works with any kibble

Cons

  • Expensive per pound
  • Raw product, so handle hygienically

Check price on Amazon

4. All American Canine Weight Gainer Powder

Best powder

All American Canine high calorie weight gainer powder for dogs

A high-calorie powder made from beef broth protein, whey protein, flaxseed, liver and vegetables, mixed into food. It’s made in the USA and gives about 60 servings per container.

Powder gainers are handy for dogs that fill up quickly. Stir it into a little warm water first, so it coats the kibble rather than sinking to the bottom.

Pros

  • Adds calories without bigger meals
  • Real protein sources
  • Made in USA

Cons

  • Whey may not suit dairy-sensitive dogs
  • Not a fix for underlying illness

Check price on Amazon

5. Miracle Vet High-Calorie Weight Gainer Gel

Best for recovery

Miracle Vet high calorie weight gainer gel supplement for dogs

A calorie-rich gel with fish oil and 29 vitamins and minerals. It’s commonly used to help dogs recovering from illness or surgery, rescues coming in underweight, and nursing mothers.

Most dogs lick it straight from your finger, which is useful when appetite is low. Use it as a short-term support, with your vet’s go-ahead.

Pros

  • Easy to give, even with a poor appetite
  • Fish oil and vitamins added
  • Good for short-term recovery

Cons

  • Not a long-term diet
  • Pricey for daily use in a big dog

Check price on Amazon

How to help a Border Collie gain weight the right way

Check body condition first

Run your hands over the ribs. In a healthy Collie you feel each rib easily with a thin layer of padding. If the ribs, spine and hip bones are sharp and visible from across the room, the dog is underweight. If you can feel ribs but not see them, your Collie is probably fine.

Rule out medical causes

Worms, dental pain, food intolerance, EPI and thyroid problems all cause weight loss. A fecal test and basic bloodwork are cheap compared with months of extra food that doesn’t work.

Add calories gradually

Increase food by about 10% a week, or switch to a denser food over 7 to 10 days. A sudden jump in fat is a common cause of diarrhea, which makes weight loss worse.

Split meals and manage stress

Three smaller meals are easier to eat than one big one. Feed in a quiet spot, away from other dogs. Anxious or over-busy Collies often eat poorly, so build in rest time.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my Border Collie so skinny?

Many are naturally lean, which is healthy. Real underweight can come from high activity, a low-calorie food, stress, worms or medical problems. If you can see ribs and hip bones, see a vet.

How can I fatten up my Border Collie quickly?

Don’t aim for fast. Switch to a calorie-dense food like VICTOR Hi-Pro Plus, add a high-calorie topper, and increase portions about 10% a week. Fast weight gain usually means fat, not muscle, and can upset the stomach.

Are weight gainer supplements safe for dogs?

Reputable ones are generally safe as short-term support. Your vet should rule out illness first, and the base diet should still be a complete, quality food.

What human foods help a dog gain weight?

Plain cooked eggs, plain cooked chicken or beef, and plain canned pumpkin are safe additions in small amounts. Avoid fatty table scraps, cooked bones, onion, garlic and anything with xylitol.

Final thoughts

Start with a vet check, then switch to a denser food. VICTOR Hi-Pro Plus is the simplest single change for most thin Border Collies. If appetite is the real problem, a meaty topper like Stella and Chewy’s usually gets the bowl emptied. Weigh your dog every two weeks and stop adding once you can feel ribs under a thin layer of padding.

We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides what makes the list.