Best Raw Dog Food for Border Collies: Our Top Picks

Raw feeding has a loyal following among Border Collie owners, especially in working and sports homes. People say they see better coats, smaller stools and keener interest at mealtimes. Vets are more cautious. Raw meat can carry bacteria like Salmonella and Listeria, and home-made raw diets are easy to get wrong on calcium and other minerals.

The good news is that you don’t have to choose between a bag of kibble and a freezer full of mince. Commercial raw foods now come in several forms: frozen, freeze-dried, air-dried, and kibble coated or mixed with raw pieces. Here are the options we’d consider for an active Collie, from full raw to a gentle step in that direction.

Our picks at a glance

Product Best for
Primal Kibble in the Raw (Beef) Raw without the freezer Check price
Team Dog Raw Frozen Dog Food Owners committed to fresh raw Check price
Badlands Ranch Air-Dried Beef A gently cooked alternative Check price
Instinct Raw Boost (Beef) Dipping a toe into raw Check price
Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grains (Wild Ocean) Fish-based and grain-inclusive Check price
Nature's Diet Simply Raw Making your own fresh meals Check price

How we chose these foods

We picked commercial foods that are formulated to be complete and balanced, so you aren’t guessing at nutrients. We included different formats so you can choose by budget, freezer space and how far you want to go with raw. Before switching, especially for a puppy or a dog with health issues, talk it through with your vet.

Product details and images come from Amazon’s product data. Prices change often, so we link to the live listing instead of quoting a number that will be out of date next week.

The best raw dog food for Border Collies

1. Primal Kibble in the Raw (Beef)

Best overall

Primal Kibble in the Raw freeze-dried beef dog food bag

Primal designed this as a direct kibble replacement: 100% freeze-dried raw bites, made with grass-fed beef, that you scoop and serve straight from the bag. No thawing, no freezer space, and the bites feel familiar to a dog used to kibble.

Primal says the recipe is backed by peer-reviewed research on digestibility. The 9 lb bag goes a reasonable way for a medium dog, though it’s still a premium-priced diet.

What stands out

  • Scoop-and-serve convenience
  • Grass-fed beef
  • Easy transition from kibble

Keep in mind

  • Premium price
  • Handle like raw meat

Check price on Amazon

2. Team Dog Raw Frozen Dog Food

Best frozen raw

Team Dog raw frozen dog food with beef, organ meat, herring and green tripe

If you want true frozen raw, Team Dog’s blend is 65% beef muscle with organ meats, herring and green tripe. Tripe is a raw feeders’ favorite for picky dogs, and herring brings omega-3s. It’s complete and balanced, and it can also be used as a topper over kibble.

Frozen raw needs freezer space and careful thawing in the fridge.

What stands out

  • Includes green tripe and herring
  • Complete and balanced
  • Works as a topper too

Keep in mind

  • Needs freezer space
  • Strict kitchen hygiene required

Check price on Amazon

3. Badlands Ranch Air-Dried Beef

Best air-dried

Badlands Ranch air-dried beef dog food bag

Air-dried food is cooked low and slow rather than left raw, which some owners prefer for safety while keeping a meat-rich, minimally processed diet. Badlands Ranch’s recipe is 87% beef, beef heart and liver plus salmon, with no corn, wheat or soy. It needs no fridge.

Use it as a full meal or as a topper. It’s dense, so portions look small.

What stands out

  • 87% real meat
  • No fridge needed
  • Lower pathogen risk than raw

Keep in mind

  • Small bag for the price
  • Portions look small; measure carefully

Check price on Amazon

4. Instinct Raw Boost (Beef)

Best raw-boosted kibble

Instinct Raw Boost dry dog food with freeze-dried raw beef bites bag

Instinct Raw Boost mixes high-protein kibble with freeze-dried raw beef pieces. USA-raised beef is the first ingredient, and the recipe is grain-free. It’s a simple way to add some raw to a dog’s diet without changing your routine.

It costs more than standard kibble but much less than full raw.

What stands out

  • Kibble convenience with raw pieces
  • Beef first ingredient
  • Large 20 lb bag

Keep in mind

  • Some dogs pick out the raw bits
  • Grain-free; discuss with your vet if needed

Check price on Amazon

5. Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grains (Wild Ocean)

Best with grains

Open Farm RawMix ancient grains wild ocean dry dog food

Open Farm’s RawMix pairs kibble with freeze-dried raw pieces and bone broth. The Wild Ocean recipe uses wild-caught whitefish, salmon and rockfish, and includes ancient grains for owners who’d rather not go grain-free. Open Farm lets you trace the origin of the ingredients.

What stands out

  • Includes grains
  • Fish-based protein
  • Traceable sourcing

Keep in mind

  • Pricey for a kibble
  • Fish smell is strong

Check price on Amazon

6. Nature's Diet Simply Raw

Best budget raw

Nature's Diet Simply Raw freeze-dried whole food meal bag

Nature’s Diet sells a freeze-dried mix that you rehydrate to make up to 18 lb of fresh food with muscle, organ, bone broth and whole egg. It’s made in small batches in the USA. Per meal, it’s one of the most affordable ways to feed a raw-style diet.

What stands out

  • Good value per meal
  • Human-grade ingredients
  • Made in the USA

Keep in mind

  • Requires mixing and fridge storage
  • Texture won’t suit every dog

Check price on Amazon

Is raw food right for your Border Collie?

The case for

Raw and minimally processed foods are generally rich in animal protein and very palatable. Many owners of active Collies like that.

The case against

Raw meat can carry harmful bacteria that affect both dogs and people, which matters in homes with young children, elderly people or anyone with a weak immune system. Raw diets also cost more. And home-made raw diets often end up unbalanced.

A middle ground

Many owners feed a good kibble and add a raw or freeze-dried topper, or use raw-boosted kibble. That gives some of the benefits with less cost and risk.

Raw feeding safety tips

  • Thaw frozen raw in the fridge, never on the counter.
  • Wash bowls, hands and surfaces after every meal.
  • Don’t leave raw food out for more than about 30 minutes.
  • Keep raw food away from young children and immune-compromised people.
  • Choose commercial diets labeled complete and balanced.
  • Transition slowly over 7 to 10 days.

Frequently asked questions

Is raw food good for Border Collies?

It can be, if it’s a complete and balanced commercial diet and handled safely. It isn’t automatically better than a high-quality kibble. Talk to your vet before switching.

Can Border Collie puppies eat raw food?

Only diets formulated for growth or all life stages. Puppies need precise calcium and phosphorus levels, and mistakes can affect bone development.

What’s the difference between freeze-dried and raw?

Freeze-dried food is usually raw food with the water removed, so it’s shelf-stable. Frozen raw is fresh food kept frozen. Both should be handled like raw meat.

How much raw food does a Border Collie eat?

Typically 2 to 3% of body weight a day for adults, more for very active or working dogs. Follow the brand’s feeding guide and adjust for body condition.

Is air-dried food raw?

Air-dried food is gently cooked at low temperatures, so it isn’t strictly raw, but it’s still minimally processed and meat-rich.

Final thoughts

If you want raw without the hassle, Primal Kibble in the Raw is the easiest place to start. Committed raw feeders will like Team Dog’s frozen blend with tripe. If you’re unsure, a raw-boosted kibble like Instinct Raw Boost is a gentle middle ground. Whatever you choose, pick a complete and balanced diet, take kitchen hygiene seriously, and check in with your vet.

We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides what makes the list.