Chuckit! Ultra Ball Review: The Fetch Ball for Collies

Our verdict
The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is the fetch ball we would hand most Border Collie owners first. The medium size fits the breed’s weight range, the thick rubber holds up far better than a tennis ball, and it floats for water retrieves. It is not a chew toy, but as a ball for throwing and chasing it is hard to beat.
- Best for: Fetch-crazy Collies who play in fields, on beaches and in lakes
- Not for: Unsupervised chewing or very large, heavy-jawed dogs
- Size for most Border Collies: Medium (2.5 inch), made for dogs 20 to 60 lb
Every Border Collie owner knows the tennis ball graveyard. There is one under the deck, two in the hedge and a slimy, flattened one in the car that your dog still treats like a prize. Felt balls fuzz, soak up mud and split open faster than you can replace them.
The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is the usual answer when people get tired of that cycle. It is a solid rubber ball with a bright finish, a strong bounce and a size that suits a 30 to 45 lb herding dog. Here is what it does well, where it falls short and how to choose the right pack.
What the Chuckit! Ultra Ball is (and isn’t)
The Ultra Ball is a fetch ball. It is made from durable rubber with a textured surface and an extra-thick core, designed to bounce higher than a standard tennis ball and float in water. It fits medium Chuckit! launchers, which is how many Collie owners use it.
It is not an indestructible chew toy. Chuckit! describes it as tough enough for rough fetch games, and the rubber is far sturdier than felt. But a Collie who lies down and gnaws a ball for an hour can still wear it down. Treat it as a retrieving toy and put it away when the game ends.
It is also not a puzzle or enrichment toy. Its job is simple: fly far, bounce unpredictably and survive being carried back again and again.
Key specs
| Material | Durable rubber with a textured surface and thick core |
|---|---|
| Size reviewed | Medium, 2.5 inch diameter |
| Recommended dog weight | 20 to 60 lb (medium) |
| Floats | Yes |
| Launcher fit | Medium Chuckit! launchers |
| Pack options | 2-pack, 4-pack, or 8-pack with cleaning bucket |
Which size to get
Medium (2.5 inch)
Our pick for nearly every Border Collie. Chuckit! rates it for dogs 20 to 60 lb, which covers the breed from a slim female to a big working male. It fits standard medium launchers.
Large
Worth a look only if your Collie is at the very top of the weight range with a big mouth, or if she likes to hold two balls at once. You will also need a launcher that fits the larger ball.
For pack size, the 2-pack is a fine trial. The 4-pack makes sense once you know your dog loves it, and the 8-pack with a cleaning bucket suits households that lose balls often or run more than one dog. The bucket lid converts into a water bowl, which is handy at the park.
Strengths
A bounce that keeps the chase interesting
Chuckit! built the Ultra Ball to outbounce a standard tennis ball. For a Collie, that means a ball that skips and changes direction, so the dog has to read it rather than simply run to a spot. It turns a plain throw into a little tracking exercise.
Durable rubber instead of felt
There is no fuzz to strip off and no seam to split. The thick rubber core is built to handle rough fetch games, and the surface rinses clean after a muddy session. Many owners also find rubber kinder to teeth than abrasive felt, which can wear enamel over time.
It floats
Plenty of Border Collies love water retrieves. The Ultra Ball floats, so you can throw it into a lake or pond and expect it to come back. That makes it a natural summer ball for swimmers.
Launcher compatible
The medium ball fits medium Chuckit! launchers. With a launcher you can throw far enough to give a fast dog a real sprint without wrecking your shoulder, and you never have to touch a slimy ball.
Drawbacks
Not a chew toy
Some Collies settle down and chew a ball between throws. Rubber holds up better than felt, but determined chewing can still damage it. Inspect the ball before each session and replace it once it is cracked or chunks start to come loose.
Easy to lose in long grass
The bright colors help, but a high-bounce ball can still roll into brush and vanish. That is one reason the larger packs make sense if you play in rough fields.
Bounce can be a lot indoors
The same bounce that makes it exciting outside makes it a menace near lamps and glassware. Save it for the yard, park or beach.
Pros
- Medium size suits the breed’s 30 to 45 lb range
- Durable rubber that outlasts tennis balls
- Floats for water retrieves
- High, unpredictable bounce
- Works with medium Chuckit! launchers
Cons
- Not designed for unsupervised chewing
- Can disappear in tall grass
- Too bouncy for indoor play
Tips to get the most from it
- Start each session with a few short throws so your dog warms up before full sprints.
- Keep sessions to 10 or 15 minutes and offer water between rounds, especially in warm weather.
- Use a clear cue to end the game, then put the ball away. This helps prevent ball obsession.
- Rotate two or three balls so a wet one can dry while you play with another.
- Check each ball for cracks or missing pieces before you throw it.
- Mix in a “drop” and “wait” before each throw to turn fetch into impulse control training.
Alternatives worth a look
If you want something to throw the Ultra Ball with, read our Chuckit! Classic Launcher review. For a wider range of options, including balls built more for chewing, see our picks for the best balls for Border Collies. And if your dog prefers pushing a big ball around like a sheep, the Chuckit! Kick Fetch is a fun change of pace.
Frequently asked questions
What size Chuckit Ultra Ball is best for a Border Collie?
Medium is the right size for most Border Collies. It measures 2.5 inches and is rated for dogs 20 to 60 lb. The ball should always be too big for your dog to swallow.
Does the Chuckit Ultra Ball float?
Yes. It floats, which makes it a good choice for dogs who love swimming and water retrieves.
Can my Border Collie chew the Ultra Ball?
It is built for fetch rather than chewing. Rubber is tougher than felt, but long chew sessions can still damage it. Supervise play and replace the ball if it cracks.
Does the medium Ultra Ball fit a Chuckit launcher?
Yes. The medium ball is designed for medium Chuckit! launchers, which are the most common size.
How do I clean a Chuckit Ultra Ball?
Rinse it with warm water and mild soap, then let it dry. The 8-pack comes with a cleaning bucket that makes this easier after muddy sessions.
Pros, Cons and Verdict
The Chuckit! Ultra Ball does one job very well. It gives a Border Collie a durable, floating, high-bounce ball in a size that fits the breed, and it works with the launchers many owners already have. Its only real weakness is that it is not a chew toy, so keep play supervised. For everyday fetch, it is the ball we would reach for first.
Prefer more balls in the box? See the 4-pack or the 8-pack with cleaning bucket.
We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our verdict.
