Nina Ottosson Dog Tornado Review: A Collie’s First Puzzle

Our verdict
The Dog Tornado is a smart first puzzle for a Border Collie. Three spinning layers and 12 hidden compartments give a quick, curious dog plenty to figure out, and the removable bones let you adjust the challenge. Most Collies will crack it within days, so treat it as a stepping stone to harder puzzles rather than a forever toy, and always supervise.
- Best for: Collies new to puzzles, rainy-day brain work, slowing down treat time
- Not for: Unsupervised play or dogs that chew plastic
- Size for most Border Collies: The standard 9.8 inch Tornado (one size)
It’s the third day of rain. Your Border Collie has already done laps of the hallway, herded the cat under the bed and is now staring at you from the doorway with that intense, unblinking look. You can’t go out, but that brain needs a job.
That’s exactly the situation puzzle toys were made for, and the Nina Ottosson Dog Tornado is one of the most popular starting points. Here’s what it is, how it suits a Collie and where it falls short.
What the Dog Tornado is (and isn’t)
The Dog Tornado is a round treat puzzle made by Outward Hound under the Nina Ottosson line. It’s a stack of three layers that spin around a central post. Each layer has compartments where you hide treats or kibble, and some of those compartments are covered with small bone-shaped pieces.
To get the food, your dog has to nose or paw the layers to rotate them and lift the bones out of the way. There are 12 hidden compartments in total.
Outward Hound rates it Level 2, which they call intermediate. In practice it sits between the very simple slide puzzles and the multi-step Level 3 toys. It includes tips for making the game easier or harder.
What it isn’t: a chew toy, a durable crate toy or something you leave out all day. It’s a hands-on game you play together, then put away.
For a Border Collie, that makes it a training tool as much as a toy. You’ll be sitting nearby, marking good choices and resetting the layers, which turns 15 minutes of rainy-day restlessness into structured brain work. It’s especially handy for young dogs that can’t yet do long runs, older Collies slowing down physically, and dogs on crate rest after an injury who still need something to think about.
Key specs
| Brand | Outward Hound (Nina Ottosson line) |
|---|---|
| Type | Spinning treat puzzle |
| Difficulty | Level 2, Intermediate |
| Diameter | 9.8 inches |
| Treat compartments | 12 hidden compartments |
| Layers | 3 spinning layers |
| Ways to play | Spin layers, lift bones |
| Material | Plastic |
| Puppy version | Puppy Tornado, also Level 2, 9.8 inches |
Strengths
Real thinking, not just licking
Lick mats and stuffed toys are great, but they’re mostly about patience. The Tornado makes your dog solve something. Spinning one layer can reveal food or cover it up again, so your Collie has to learn which actions pay off. That kind of problem-solving is what this breed craves.
Outward Hound says 15 minutes of brain-engaging play equals 30 minutes of physical activity. We’d take that as a rough guide rather than science, but any Collie owner knows a mentally tired dog is a calmer dog.
Easy to make harder
Start with treats in open compartments and no bones. Once your dog has the idea of spinning, add the bones. Then mix food between the layers so your dog has to work through all three. That built-in progression is useful for a breed that learns fast.
Compact and quick to set up
At under 10 inches across, it fits on a kitchen floor, a crate tray or a small apartment rug. Loading it takes under a minute, so it’s realistic to use daily, even before work.
A puppy version for young Collies
If you have a Collie puppy, there’s a Puppy Tornado with the same 9.8 inch size and Level 2 rating. Outward Hound pitches it as a way to introduce puppies to treat games and redirect unwanted habits like chewing and barking.
Drawbacks
Smart Collies outgrow it
This is the big one. Border Collies are among the quickest problem-solvers in the dog world. Plenty will figure out the Tornado in a session or two. After that, it becomes a fun feeder rather than a real puzzle. Plan to move on to something harder, like the Dog Brick or a Level 3 puzzle.
Plastic pieces need supervision
The bones are small and removable, and the whole thing is plastic. A frustrated or mouthy Collie may try to chew the bones or carry the toy off. Stay in the room, and put it away when the game is over.
Some dogs try to flip it
Pushy dogs sometimes skip the spinning and try to tip the puzzle over or paw at it hard. If that happens, guide your dog back to nosing the layers and reward gentle attempts.
Pros
- Real problem-solving with spinning layers
- 12 compartments and removable bones for adjustable difficulty
- Compact 9.8 inch size
- Puppy version available
Cons
- Many Collies master it quickly
- Plastic and small parts need supervision
- Not a chew or crate toy
Tips to get the most from it
- Introduce it with the bones removed and very smelly treats, so your dog wins quickly.
- Use part of your Collie’s daily kibble so the extra treats don’t add up.
- Mark and reward the moment your dog spins a layer with its nose. That speeds up learning.
- Rotate it with other puzzles so it stays fresh.
- Put it on a non-slip mat if your dog keeps pushing it across the floor.
- Wash it regularly, since kibble dust and saliva build up in the compartments.
Alternatives worth a look
If your Collie is already a puzzle pro, the Dog Brick adds sliders and lids for a tougher challenge. Read our Nina Ottosson Dog Brick review for details. For a wider range of options at every level, see our puzzle toy picks for Border Collies. And if you want something your dog can bat around the room, the KONG Wobbler is a good, tougher alternative.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Dog Tornado too easy for a Border Collie?
It may become easy after a few sessions. It’s still a great introduction to puzzle play, and you can add challenge by using the bones and spreading food across all three layers. When it gets too simple, move to a Level 3 puzzle.
Can I leave my Collie alone with the Dog Tornado?
No. It’s made of plastic with small removable bones, so it should be used only with supervision and put away afterward.
What treats work best in the Tornado?
Small, dry pieces such as kibble or tiny training treats work well. Soft or greasy treats can stick in the compartments and make cleaning harder.
What is the difference between the Dog Tornado and the Puppy Tornado?
Both are 9.8 inch Level 2 spinning puzzles. The Puppy Tornado is marketed for young dogs with little puzzle experience, while the standard Tornado is aimed at adult dogs of all ages.
How often should I use a puzzle toy with my Collie?
Once a day is a good rhythm for many dogs, often at mealtime. Keep sessions to 10 or 15 minutes and stop while your dog is still enjoying it.
Pros, Cons and Verdict
The Nina Ottosson Dog Tornado is a well-designed, affordable way to give a Border Collie’s brain something to chew on. It teaches the basics of puzzle solving, and the adjustable difficulty keeps it interesting for a while. Its main limit is that clever Collies outgrow it, so see it as the first rung on the ladder, not the last.
We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our verdict.
