Stewart Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Review: Who It Suits (and Who It Doesn’t)

Our verdict
Stewart Freeze-Dried Beef Liver is a strong pick for Border Collie owners who need a treat that beats every distraction, from sheep to squirrels. It’s a single ingredient, it keeps at room temperature, and most dogs go wild for it. Skip it if you want a soft, mess-free treat for your pocket, or if your dog has a sensitive stomach that rich food upsets.
- Best for: High-value rewards in distracting places
- Not for: Owners who hate crumbs, or dogs with touchy digestion
- Size for most Border Collies: 14 oz tub
Every Border Collie owner eventually meets the moment when kibble stops working. You’re in the park, your dog has spotted a squirrel, and the dry biscuit in your hand is suddenly worth nothing. That’s what high-value treats are for, and freeze-dried liver is about as high-value as it gets for most dogs.
Stewart has been making freeze-dried liver for a long time, and its tubs turn up in a lot of training bags. It’s not fancy. It’s dried beef liver in a tub. The interesting questions for a collie owner are practical ones: how small you can break it, how much your dog can have, and which size to buy so it doesn’t go stale.
What Stewart Freeze-Dried Beef Liver is (and isn't)
According to the listing, these treats are 100% beef liver, freeze-dried, with nothing else added. Stewart says the liver is USDA-certified, the treats are made in the USA in small batches, and they’re grain free and gluten free. They need no refrigeration and come in a resealable tub or pouch. The brand lists them as safe for all life stages and also suitable for cats.
What they aren’t is a soft training treat. Freeze-dried liver is light and dry, with a crumbly texture. Stewart notes that treat size varies and that powder naturally collects at the bottom, which the brand suggests using as a meal topper. They also aren’t a complete food. These are treats, and liver is rich, so they should stay a small part of your dog’s daily diet.
Key specs
| Brand | Stewart |
|---|---|
| Ingredient | 100% beef liver |
| Form | Freeze-dried pieces, varied size |
| Sizes on Amazon | 4 oz tub, 8 oz pouch, 14 oz tub, 21 oz tub |
| Pieces (per brand) | About 90 (4 oz), up to 180 (8 oz), up to 315 (14 oz), up to 475 (21 oz) |
| Storage | Room temperature, resealable container |
| Diet notes | Grain free, gluten free, single ingredient |
| Made in | USA (per brand) |
Which size fits a Border Collie household
All four options are the same treat. The choice comes down to how fast you’ll get through it, and since collies tend to be trained a lot, most owners use more than they expect.
4 oz tub
A sensible trial size. Stewart says it holds about 90 pieces, which you can break into far more small training bits.
8 oz pouch
Lighter to carry than a tub. Good for a dog that gets liver only for tough training sessions.
14 oz tub Our pick
The best balance for an active collie in regular training. The brand estimates up to 315 pieces, around a two-month supply.
21 oz tub
For multi-dog homes or owners doing daily sports training. Keep the lid sealed so the last third stays fresh.
What we like
It wins against real distractions
Border Collies can be food-motivated, but their drive to chase often wins. A smelly, rich treat like liver gives you a better chance of getting attention back when a bike goes by or another dog runs past. Owners often keep it for the hardest moments, like recall in the park, rather than everyday sits in the kitchen. That way it stays special.
Just one ingredient
The ingredient list is a single line: beef liver. That’s useful if your vet has asked you to keep track of exactly what your dog eats, or if you’re trying to avoid grains and fillers. It also makes it easy to know what you’re adding to your dog’s day.
Easy to break into tiny pieces
Collies learn fast, and good training means lots of quick rewards, sometimes twenty or thirty in a short session. Freeze-dried liver snaps and crumbles easily, so one piece can become several pea-sized rewards. Smaller pieces mean more reps without overfeeding.
Keeps without a fridge
Because it’s freeze-dried and sealed, you can keep a tub in the car or training bag. That beats carrying cheese or cooked chicken on a long day out.
What we don’t like
Crumbs and powder everywhere
The dry texture that makes it easy to break also makes it messy. Pieces crumble in your pocket and leave dust in a treat pouch. Stewart frames the powder as a meal topper, which is fair, but you’ll still be cleaning your jacket pockets.
Rich food is easy to overdo
Liver is rich, and a dog that gets too much in one day may end up with a loose stomach. It’s easy to overdo during a long training session with a bright, eager collie. Keep pieces tiny, count them roughly, and reduce dinner a little on heavy training days.
Uneven piece size
Stewart says piece size varies, and in practice that means some chunks are large and some are dust. You’ll usually need to break the bigger pieces before training.
Pros
- Single ingredient: beef liver
- High value for distracting situations
- Breaks into very small pieces
- No refrigeration needed
- Several sizes
Cons
- Crumbly and dusty
- Rich, so easy to overfeed
- Uneven piece sizes
Tips to get the most from it
- Break a handful into pea-sized bits before a session and keep them in a separate pouch. You’ll train faster and use far less.
- Save liver for hard moments like recall, working near livestock, or calm behavior around bikes, and use something plainer for easy cues.
- Keep treats to roughly 10% of your dog’s daily calories and trim meals on busy training days. Ask your vet if you’re unsure how much is right.
- Shake the powder from the bottom of the tub over dinner so nothing is wasted.
- Close the lid firmly every time. Freeze-dried treats can soften if moisture gets in.
- Introduce it slowly. Give a few pieces the first day and watch for any tummy upset.
Alternatives worth a look
Pupford Freeze-Dried Training Treats are already tiny and uniform, so you skip the breaking-up step. They’re worth a look if crumbs drive you mad. See our Pupford review.
Blue Buffalo Blue Bits are soft, moist training treats that don’t crumble in a pocket. They’re less intense than liver but cleaner to carry. Our Blue Bits review covers them.
Frequently asked questions
Is freeze-dried liver good for training a Border Collie?
Yes, as a high-value reward. Most dogs find it very tempting, which helps when you're competing with movement and other distractions. Break it into very small pieces so you can reward often without overfeeding.
How much Stewart beef liver can a Border Collie have?
Keep all treats to roughly 10% of daily calories, and remember liver is rich. Small pieces spread through a training session are better than a big handful. Your vet can give you a figure based on your dog's weight and activity.
Can Border Collie puppies eat freeze-dried liver?
Stewart lists the treats as safe for all life stages. With puppies, use very small pieces, introduce them slowly, and check with your vet about treat amounts during growth.
Does Stewart beef liver need to be refrigerated?
No. The brand says it stores at room temperature in its resealable container. Keep the lid closed tightly so moisture doesn't soften the pieces.
Bottom line
Stewart Freeze-Dried Beef Liver does one job very well: it gives you a reward that can compete with a Border Collie’s interest in everything else. The single ingredient is easy to understand, it keeps without a fridge, and it breaks into tiny training bits. The 14 oz tub is the size most collie owners will get through without it going stale.
Just accept the crumbs, keep the pieces small and use it with some restraint. It’s a treat for the hard moments, not a snack for every sit.
We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our verdict.
