Jack and Pup Bully Sticks Review: Pros, Cons and Verdict

Our verdict
Jack&Pup bully sticks are a good choice for Border Collie owners who want a single-ingredient chew to help their dog settle after exercise or training. The 12 inch thick sticks suit a typical collie and are easier to take away safely before they get too short. Skip them if you can’t supervise chewing, if your dog gulps food, or if you’re sensitive to smell, because even lower-odor bully sticks still smell like beef.
- Best for: Settling a busy collie after exercise
- Not for: Unsupervised chewing or dogs that gulp
- Size for most Border Collies: 12 inch thick sticks
A Border Collie that’s had a good run and a training session still often can’t switch off. It paces, picks up a toy, drops it, stares at you. Chewing is one of the most reliable ways to help that busy brain settle, because the steady gnawing seems to calm a lot of dogs down. That’s where a long-lasting chew earns its place.
Bully sticks are one of the most popular options, and Jack&Pup is one of the brands you’ll see most on Amazon. This review looks at what the listing promises, which length makes sense for a 30 to 45 lb collie, and the safety habits that matter with any chew of this kind.
What Jack&Pup bully sticks are (and aren't)
These are beef pizzle chews, dried into firm sticks. Jack&Pup describes them as single ingredient and rawhide-free, sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle raised without added hormones or antibiotics. The 12 inch listing adds that they’re processed in a USDA Human Grade Certified and inspected facility, and says the thick sticks are made to be lower odor than many other bully sticks.
They come in 6 and 12 inch lengths and several pack sizes. The 12 inch thick sticks are listed for medium and large dogs from 25 to 75 lb, which puts a typical Border Collie right in the middle of the range.
What they aren’t is indestructible. A determined chewer will work through a stick, and the end piece is the part that needs watching. They’re also calorie-dense, so they count toward your dog’s daily food.
Key specs
| Brand | Jack&Pup |
|---|---|
| Ingredient | Beef pizzle (single ingredient) |
| Lengths on Amazon | 6 inch and 12 inch |
| Pack sizes | 5, 10 and 25 count, depending on length |
| Dog size (12 inch, per brand) | Medium and large dogs, 25 to 75 lb |
| Sourcing (per brand) | Grass-fed, free-range cattle, no added hormones or antibiotics |
| Rawhide | Rawhide-free |
Which size fits a Border Collie
Longer is usually safer for a medium dog, because you can take the stick away while there’s still plenty left to hold. Here’s how the options compare.
12 inch, 5 pack Our pick
The best fit for most collies. Long enough to last, and easy to remove before the end gets risky.
12 inch, 10 pack
Same length in a bigger bag, for households that use chews a few times a week.
6 inch, 5 pack
Thick, but short. Fine for a quick chew with close supervision; it gets to the risky stub stage faster.
6 inch, 25 pack
A bulk option for short chews or training-session rewards cut into pieces.
What we like
It gives a busy collie something to do
Border Collies that don’t have a job tend to invent one, and chewing furniture or skirting boards is a common choice. A long chew offered after exercise gives that energy somewhere to go. Many owners use one as part of a settle routine: walk, short training game, then a chew on the mat.
Simple ingredient list
One ingredient, no rawhide, and the brand says no additives or preservatives. If you like knowing exactly what your dog is eating, that’s appealing. It’s also easier to spot the cause if a new chew doesn’t agree with your dog.
Lengths that suit a medium dog
The 12 inch thick option is listed for 25 to 75 lb dogs, a sensible match for a collie. You also get choices in count, so you can try a small pack before committing to a big bag.
What we don’t like
The end piece needs watching
Every bully stick eventually becomes a short stub, and that stub is a choking and blockage risk if swallowed whole. A collie that gets excited and tries to gulp the last bit is exactly the dog to watch. You have to be there to take it away, which rules it out as a leave-alone chew.
Lower odor is still odor
Jack&Pup says these are lower odor than many bully sticks, and some owners may find that’s true. Still, a chewed, damp bully stick on a rug smells like what it is. Use a washable mat or chew zone.
Calories add up
Bully sticks are rich, and a long one can be a meaningful part of a medium dog’s daily calories. Cut back meals a little on chew days, especially for a less active collie.
Pros
- Single ingredient, rawhide-free
- 12 inch size suits a 30 to 45 lb dog
- Good for settling after exercise
- Several lengths and pack sizes
Cons
- Must be supervised, especially near the end
- Still has a beefy smell
- Calorie-dense
Tips to get the most from it
- Always supervise, and take the stick away when it’s short enough to fit in your dog’s mouth whole. Swap it for a treat so your collie learns to give it up happily.
- Introduce chews slowly. Offer ten or fifteen minutes the first few times and watch for any tummy upset.
- Use a bully stick holder or simply hold the end for a dog that tries to swallow big chunks.
- Chew on a washable mat or towel to keep the smell and stains off your floor.
- Count the chew toward your dog’s daily food and trim meals a little on chew days.
- Store opened packs in a sealed container in a cool, dry spot.
Alternatives worth a look
Best Bully Sticks is another popular bully stick brand with thick and jumbo options.
Himalayan Dog Chew is a hard cheese chew with no meat at all. It’s a good alternative for dogs that don’t do well on bully sticks, though it’s very hard.
Frequently asked questions
Are Jack&Pup bully sticks safe for Border Collies?
They can be, with supervision. Choose a length that suits your dog, watch while it chews, and take the stick away before the end piece is small enough to swallow. No chew is completely risk-free, so never leave a dog alone with one.
What size bully stick does a Border Collie need?
For most adult collies, a 12 inch thick stick is the safer bet. It lasts longer and gives you more to hold onto when you take it away. Shorter sticks get down to a risky stub much faster.
Can Border Collie puppies have bully sticks?
Many owners use them during teething, and the brand mentions teething relief for puppies. Keep sessions short, supervise closely, and check with your vet about treat amounts while your puppy is growing.
How often can I give my collie a bully stick?
A few times a week is common, but it depends on your dog's size, activity and diet. Count it as part of the day's food. If your dog gains weight or gets a loose stomach, cut back.
Bottom line
Jack&Pup bully sticks are a straightforward, single-ingredient chew that suits a Border Collie well. The 12 inch thick sticks fit the breed’s size, last long enough to help an active dog settle, and leave you enough length to take away safely.
The trade-offs are the same as for any bully stick: you need to supervise, watch the end piece, and count the calories. Do that, and they’re a useful tool for teaching a busy collie to relax.
We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our verdict.
