Best Bully Sticks Review: Worth It for a Border Collie?

Our verdict
Best Bully Sticks makes simple, single-ingredient beef chews in several thicknesses, and the 12 inch sticks are the easiest fit for a typical Border Collie. They’re a good tool for winding a busy collie down after work or play. Skip them if you can’t sit with your dog while it chews, or if a strong natural smell in the house is a dealbreaker.
- Best for: Wind-down chews for active adult collies
- Not for: Unsupervised chewing or smell-sensitive homes
- Size for most Border Collies: 12 inch sticks
First, a point that trips people up: Best Bully Sticks is a brand name. Search for it and you’ll get a mix of their products and every other company’s “best bully sticks” list. This review is about the brand itself, which sells beef bully sticks in standard, thick and jumbo styles on Amazon.
For a Border Collie owner the question is practical. Collies are rarely the heaviest chewers, but they’re busy dogs that need a way to settle, and a bored adolescent collie will happily turn a table leg into a project. A long, single-ingredient chew can fill that gap, as long as you pick a sensible size and stay nearby while it’s being chewed.
What Best Bully Sticks are (and aren't)
The brand describes its sticks as 100% beef with no artificial preservatives, colors, flavors or other additives. Some listings specify grass-fed beef. They’re rawhide-free, chicken-free and grain-free, according to the product details. The thick 6 inch sticks are aimed at strong chewers among medium and large breeds, while the 12 inch standard sticks are listed for medium or large dogs.
Best Bully Sticks is fairly candid about two things. It warns the natural scent is something you might not love. On the jumbo 12 inch sticks, it also says aggressive chewers and large dogs will typically finish one in a single sitting. So these are long-lasting in the sense of a good session, not something that lasts a week.
They also aren’t a toy you can leave in the crate. Like any edible chew, the last few inches need watching.
Key specs
| Brand | Best Bully Sticks |
|---|---|
| Ingredient | 100% beef (bully stick) |
| Styles on Amazon | Thick 6 inch, standard 12 inch, jumbo 12 inch |
| Pack sizes shown | 5 or 10 count (thick 6 inch), 8 oz (12 inch), 4 count (jumbo 12 inch) |
| Free from (per brand) | Rawhide, chicken, grain, artificial additives |
| Recommended for (per brand) | Medium and large dogs, depending on style |
Which size fits a Border Collie
For a 30 to 45 lb dog, length matters more than thickness. A longer stick gives you something to hold and lets you swap it out before it becomes a swallowable stub.
12 inch, 8 oz Our pick
Listed for medium or large dogs and the most practical length for a collie. Sold by weight rather than count.
Jumbo 12 inch, 4 count
Thicker and long. Better for a strong chewer, but the brand notes big dogs may finish one in one sitting.
Thick 6 inch, 10 count
Thick enough to slow a chewer down, but short. Watch closely and take it away early.
Thick 6 inch, 5 count
A small pack to see whether your collie likes them and how its stomach handles them.
What we like
A short, clean ingredient list
One ingredient and no artificial additives, according to the brand. If you’re cutting out rawhide or chicken, it’s easy to check that box. That simplicity also helps if you’re watching for food sensitivities, though persistent tummy or skin issues are a conversation for your vet.
Useful for a settle routine
Many collies struggle to go from busy to calm. A chew after a walk or a training session gives them an easy, quiet job, and plenty of owners find their dog naps afterward. It’s also a handy way to keep a young collie occupied while you cook dinner, provided you’re in the same room.
Several thickness options
Having standard, thick and jumbo styles means you can match the chew to your dog. A gentle chewer may be fine with standard 12 inch sticks; a dog that crunches through things quickly may need the jumbo version to make it last.
What we don’t like
The smell is real
The brand openly says you might not love the scent, and the jumbo listing even describes a smoky aroma. Once a stick is wet from chewing, it marks rugs and blankets. Give chews on a hard floor or a washable towel.
Not as long-lasting as some owners expect
By the brand’s own account, a strong chewer may finish a jumbo stick in one go. A Border Collie with strong jaws and a lot of drive can work through a thinner stick fast. Don’t count on one to last through a whole afternoon.
Supervision is non-negotiable
The stub at the end is the dangerous part. An excited dog may try to swallow it whole, which risks choking or a blockage. You need to be there to swap it for a treat. That makes these unsuitable for crate time or for leaving with a dog while you’re out.
Pros
- Single ingredient beef, no additives (per brand)
- Rawhide-, chicken- and grain-free
- Several lengths and thicknesses
- Helps a busy dog settle
Cons
- Strong natural smell
- Strong chewers finish them quickly
- Needs constant supervision
Tips to get the most from it
- Pick 12 inch sticks for most collies, and thicker styles only if yours chews hard and fast.
- Take the stick away once it’s about the length of your dog’s mouth, and trade it for a small treat so giving it up feels like a good deal.
- Try a bully stick holder if your dog tends to gulp. The brand itself suggests pairing jumbo sticks with one.
- Start with short sessions for the first few chews and watch for loose stools.
- Count bully sticks as part of the day’s food, and keep all treats to about 10% of daily calories.
- Keep chewing in one spot, like a mat in the kitchen, to contain the smell.
Alternatives worth a look
Jack&Pup Bully Sticks are a similar single-ingredient chew, with a lower-odor claim on some listings and a 12 inch size listed for 25 to 75 lb dogs. Read our Jack and Pup review.
Earth Animal No-Hide Chews are a rawhide alternative made differently from bully sticks, worth a look if your dog doesn’t tolerate pizzle chews.
Frequently asked questions
Is Best Bully Sticks a brand or a ranking?
It's a brand. The company sells bully sticks and other chews under the Best Bully Sticks name. This review covers that brand's products, not a ranking of different makers.
Which Best Bully Sticks size suits a Border Collie?
The 12 inch sticks are the most practical for a typical 30 to 45 lb collie, because they leave plenty to hold and remove safely. Thick or jumbo styles suit dogs that chew hard. Short 6 inch sticks need especially close watching.
How long does a bully stick last a Border Collie?
It varies a lot with the dog. A gentle chewer may take several sessions, while a strong chewer can finish one in a single sitting, as the brand itself notes for its jumbo sticks. Treat it as one good chew session rather than an all-day item.
Are bully sticks safe for Border Collies?
They can be a reasonable choice with supervision. Choose a length that suits your dog, stay with them while they chew, and remove the end before it can be swallowed. Introduce them slowly and check with your vet if your dog has a sensitive stomach.
Bottom line
Best Bully Sticks offers a straightforward, single-ingredient chew in enough sizes to suit most dogs. For a Border Collie, the 12 inch sticks are the sensible starting point: long enough to keep a busy dog occupied after exercise, and long enough to take away safely.
Go in with realistic expectations about smell and how fast a determined chewer gets through one, and always supervise. Used that way, they’re a solid part of a settle routine.
We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our verdict.
