Border Collies are widely recognized as one of the most intelligent and agile dog breeds in the world. Originally bred for herding livestock, particularly sheep, their remarkable herding abilities are not only instinctual but also refined through training and generations of selective breeding. But how do Border Collies herd, and what makes them so good at it? Let’s explore the fascinating science and behavior behind their legendary herding skills.
The Origins of the Border Collie’s Herding Instinct
To understand how Border Collies herd, we need to start at the beginning. Border Collies originated along the Anglo-Scottish border, where farmers needed a dog that was fast, responsive, and could control livestock with minimal guidance.
Unlike some other herding breeds that use barking or nipping to move animals, Border Collies primarily use “eye” — an intense, focused stare — combined with calculated body movements to direct sheep with precision. This style is known as “strong eye herding.”
The Science Behind Their Herding Behavior
1. Instinctual Behavior Rooted in Predatory Sequence
Herding in Border Collies is essentially a modified form of the wolf’s predatory sequence. While a wild predator might stalk, chase, grab, and kill, herding dogs exhibit a truncated version: they stalk, chase, and circle — but they don’t attack.
This controlled predatory drive allows Border Collies to move livestock without harming them, which is what makes them so invaluable to farmers.
2. The Power of “The Eye”
One of the most iconic traits of Border Collies is their use of “the eye.” This is a deeply penetrating stare used to intimidate and control livestock. By lowering their heads, narrowing their eyes, and moving slowly, they can guide sheep with extraordinary precision.
Sheep naturally respond to this visual pressure and will move in the opposite direction of the dog’s gaze.
3. Flanking and Gathering
Border Collies use strategic movements to flank (circle) the herd and position themselves in a way that moves animals toward the handler. One of the most common tasks is “gathering,” where the dog brings the livestock to the shepherd.
They instinctively know how to create the right amount of pressure to move sheep without scattering them — a talent honed over generations.
The Role of Training in Herding
While herding instincts are strong in Border Collies, training is essential to refine and control these behaviors. Herding commands like “come by” (move clockwise) and “away to me” (move counterclockwise) are used to guide their movements around livestock.
Handlers also use whistles and hand signals to direct dogs over long distances — a necessity in large pastures or hill farms.
Early training often begins as young as 8 to 12 weeks old, using low-pressure environments to shape the dog’s responses and introduce them to basic herding commands.
Common Herding Commands Used by Border Collies
Here are a few essential herding commands Border Collies learn:
- “Come by” – Move clockwise around the herd.
- “Away to me” – Move counterclockwise.
- “Lie down” – Stop and lie still, often used to reduce pressure on the livestock.
- “Walk up” – Approach the stock slowly and directly.
- “That’ll do” – Signals the dog to stop working and return to the handler.
Can Pet Border Collies Still Herd?
Yes! Even if your Border Collie has never seen a sheep, chances are their instincts will still kick in if given the chance. Many pet owners notice their Border Collies trying to herd children, other pets, or even cars. This behavior may seem quirky, but it’s a sign of their deeply embedded instincts.
To channel this energy in a healthy way, many owners participate in activities like:
- Herding trials
- Agility training
- Treibball (urban herding using exercise balls)
These activities provide excellent mental and physical stimulation and allow Border Collies to do what they were born to do.
Final Thoughts
So, how do Border Collies herd? Through a unique combination of instinct, intelligence, body language, and training, they’re able to move livestock with grace and control unlike any other breed. Whether on a farm or in a suburban backyard, their drive to herd is always present — a beautiful example of nature and nurture working together.
If you’re a proud Border Collie owner or just fascinated by their abilities, understanding this herding behavior can help you better connect with and care for this incredible breed.
